Jibreel
Join 5,000+ Muslims
According to the Hanafi school of thought (madhhab), the time for the Isha prayer begins at the disappearance of the evening twilight (after Maghrib) and lasts all the way until Fajr (dawn).
In other words, technically Isha can be prayed anytime during the night, up until the moment Fajr starts. However, this does not mean one should habitually delay Isha until the last moment. In fact, Hanafi scholars emphasize that it is “prohibitively disliked” (makruh tahrimi) to unnecessarily pray Isha late past the "midpoint of the night" (note: this is not midnight / 12:00 am.
In Hanafi fiqh, Isha time “ends” at the start of Fajr. Any Isha prayed before true dawn is considered prayed on time (ada’) and not late (qada’).
Classical Hanafi texts, such as Mukhtasar al-Quduri, state: “The beginning of Isha time is when the twilight departs, and the end of its time is as long as the second Fajr (true dawn) has not appeared.”
In practical terms, this means if Fajr begins at 5:00 am, you have until just before 5:00 am to complete Isha. The last permissible moment for Isha is right before Fajr begins.
Does that mean you should wait that long? No. The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) actually encouraged praying Isha within the first half of the night. Hanafi scholars agree that while the absolute cutoff for Isha is Fajr, delaying the prayer beyond the midpoint of the night is disliked. In other words, the “end time” for Isha, ideally, is the halfway point between Maghrib and Fajr, not Fajr itself. Any prayer offered after this halfway mark, though technically within the valid time, is considered to be in an undesirable time without a valid reason. This guideline helps ensure that we don’t procrastinate so much that we’re rushing at the last minute or risking missing the prayer.
It is preferred to pray Isha before the "Midpoint of the Night". Many people assume this means 12:00 am, but in Islamic terminology “midnight” (the midpoint of the night) is not a fixed clock time. Instead, it’s calculated based on the interval between Maghrib and Fajr.
The night, in Islamic law, starts at Maghrib and ends at Fajr, and its midpoint is exactly halfway between those two times. This means the midpoint can change depending on the season and your location. Midnight (12:00 am) might coincide with the Islamic midpoint in some parts of the year, but often it does not.
How to calculate the midpoint of the night:
Example:
If Maghrib was at 9:00 pm and Fajr the next day is at 4:00 am, the total night length is 7 hours. Half of 7 hours is 3.5 hours. Adding 3.5 hours to 9:00 pm gives 12:30 am. In this case, 12:30 am is the midpoint of the night.
Isha prayer time would technically continue after 12:30 am up until 4:00 am, but a Hanafi Muslim should avoid delaying Isha past 12:30 am, since that’s the beginning of the disliked time. For another example, if Maghrib is at 8:00 pm and Fajr at 4:00 am, the night is 8 hours long, so the midpoint is 4 hours after Maghrib – which is 12:00 am .
As you can see, the midpoint is not always the same as 12 o’clock midnight; it depends on the Maghrib and Fajr times each day.
Hanafi scholars say it is “prohibitively disliked” (makruh tahrimi) to intentionally delay Isha past the midway point of the night. Prohibitively disliked is a strong term in Hanafi law – it means the action is very close to sinful and not acceptable to do without a valid reason. In effect, doing so could incur blame and sin, even though it’s not labeled outright haram.
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) indicated wisdom in not overly delaying the Isha prayer. He mentioned, “Had I not feared difficulty for my Ummah (community), I would have instructed them to delay Isha prayer to a third or half of the night.” This hadith shows that praying a bit later into the night (within the first half) can be permissible and was considered if it weren’t hard on people. However, beyond the halfway point, the virtue of the prayer diminishes greatly.
In fact, narrations explain that praying Isha in the first third of the night is best, the second third (up to half) is less virtuous but still acceptable, and after half the night it is the least virtuous time.
Delaying so late risks negligence: one might fall asleep or miss the prayer entirely. It also historically meant fewer people would attend Isha in congregation at the mosque, which is another reason the jurists discouraged it.
“Prohibitively disliked” vs “somewhat disliked”: There was a minor debate among Hanafi scholars about how severe the dislike is. As mentioned, many authoritative scholars (like Imam Ibn Nujaym and Imam Shurunbulali) held that praying after half the night is makruh tahrimi (strongly discouraged, nearly sinful) . Others, like Imam Ibn `Abidin, considered it makruh tanzihi (mildly disliked) but still not a good practice. For everyday Muslims, the message is clear – don’t intentionally push your Isha prayer past the midpoint unless you have a really pressing excuse.
Life happens, and sometimes you might find yourself unable to pray Isha before midnight due to circumstances. The scholars have noted that the disliked nature of praying after half the night is lifted if one has a genuine excuse. For example, if you accidentally fell asleep and woke up after the midpoint, or you had a work shift or emergency that prevented you from praying earlier, then you should still pray Isha upon remembering – and it will count as on time since it’s before Fajr. In such cases, you are not sinful for the delay, because it wasn’t done out of negligence.
The Prophet (PBUH) himself used to caution against sleeping before Isha if it would risk missing the prayer , so we should try our best to stay awake to pray on time.
It’s also worth noting that the strong dislike of delay mainly applies to those who delay without reason and miss the congregation. If you are praying alone at home, some scholars say the rule of dislike is less strict in that scenario. Nevertheless, even when praying alone, it’s superior and safer to pray before half the night passes, to follow the Prophetic practice of avoiding unnecessary activity late at night. The goal is to pray Isha with focus and not let worldly distractions or sleepiness creep in.
While Isha can technically be prayed until Fajr, the best practice for a believer is to pray it well before the “Islamic midnight” to avoid entering the disliked period. The "Islamic midnight" may be before or after 12:00am (midnight), depending on Maghreb and Fajr time.
Here are some practical tips for managing your Isha prayer time in daily life:
By incorporating these habits, you’ll ensure that you consistently pray Isha within its blessed time and avoid the risk of entering the period that scholars consider blameworthy. This also helps bring discipline to your nightly routine and keeps your worship priorities straight.
